A Nation In Protest: The Return Of The Cacerolazos

On Thursday, September 13, Argentina witnessed the largest protest to date under the administration of incumbent president Cristina Fernández de Kirchner. Reminiscent of the “cacerolazos,” the demonstrators who famously protested with pots and pans against the 2001-2002 collapse of the Argentine financial sector, thousands of Argentines gathered in the main plazas and intersections of cities across the country including Buenos Aires, Rosario, Córdoba, and Mar del Plata. Images from the manifestations have revealed Argentines chanting, holding anti-government signs, and banging kitchen pans. Using social media like Facebook and Twitter to mobilize, demonstrators gathered in front of the presidential residence in the northern Greater Buenos Aires region of Olivos while others marched along the major avenues of the capital to gather in the Plaza de Mayo.

Source: Associated Press

Since her 2011 reelection, in which she won 54 percent of the vote, President Fernández de Kirchner has steadily lost support among Argentine citizens, mainly due to feelings of both economic and personal insecurity. [1] According to the Argentine newspaper Clarín, signs held by protesters addressed a myriad of the population’s major concerns: “Cristina, give back the country. We don’t fear you,” “Stop the inflation,” “No to constitutional reform. No to the re-reelection,” “We want freedom to use our savings,” “Security,” and “No to the reduction of our liberties”. [2] These signs are the latest exemplifications of an abrupt, if not unexpected, loss of support for the once-popular president.

Much of the unrest seems to stem from recent economic legislation enacted by the national government in an attempt to stop the flow of United States dollars out of the country. These new measures have made it nearly impossible for Argentines to obtain U.S. dollars legally, giving rise to a parallel black market specializing in currency trade. With yearly inflation estimated at an alarming 25% by the Economist (about twice the value reported by the Argentine government) many middle and upper-class citizens have relied upon saving their earnings in more stable currencies, mainly in U.S. dollars. [3] Originally, the government implemented such restrictions to curb this practice in hopes of strengthening the Argentine peso, but in doing so it has angered a sizable portion of the population.

Due in large part to the release of controversial and likely fabricated economic statistics by the National Institute of Statistics and Censuses of Argentina (INDEC), citizens have lost confidence in the transparency of their government’s claims. Since 2007, INDEC has struggled to maintain credibility after glaringly underestimating the country’s inflation rate and the subsequent cost of living. For example, INDEC recently announced that a family of four can be considered above the poverty line if it spends more than 688 pesos per month on food, or approximately six pesos per person per day. However, a study by the University of Buenos Aires established the minimum daily budget as 24 pesos per person for a healthy diet, four times INDEC’s estimation. [3] To give a bit of perspective, the Economist has pointed out that six pesos, the equivalent of approximately $1.30 USD at the official exchange rate and only around $1 USD on the black market, is barely enough to buy an alfajor, a typical Argentine cookie eaten as a snack or dessert.

Source: Associated Press

Today, economic insecurity only constitutes part of the protesters’ concerns. The lack of personal security remains a bellwether of the outcry against the Fernández de Kirchner regime. While violent crime has been a source of anxiety for Argentines even before President Fernández de Kirchner took office, there is a widespread perception among the population that it has increased during her presidency. Nevertheless, the president maintains that the image of a dangerous Argentina is incited and perpetuated both by her political opponents and the media, mainly by the privately owned media giant Clarín. In spite of these assertions, many citizens still feel unsafe and threatened by the possibility of becoming a victim of a crime. One protester told Clarín that she was demanding “a free country, free of insecurity and for the government to care about us as individuals. I have lived here 60 years, and I, like the other people here, want to see a country where my grandchildren can live calmly and in peace.” [2]

Because of the government’s insufficient funding for improvements in the national rail system’s safety measures, Argentines have expressed qualms about the security of using such services. For example, a February train crash at the Once Station in Buenos Aires that killed 51 passengers and wounded 700 was a tragedy that many believe could have been avoided had the government taken steps to replace the outdated braking system that proved culpable. [4] Given the rail system’s incessant need of significant updates, Argentines are justified in their frustrations with the country’s political parties’ inaction. Indeed this sentiment has been directed at both the opposition and the ruling party, la Frente para la Victoria (FPV).

Although the large protests last Thursday night expressed a consistently negative attitude, citizens and expatriates should be encouraged by the latest Argentine demonstration of political freedom throughout the entire country. It is reassuring that Argentine citizens still feel as though they can publicly agree with or speak out against the government, no matter which party is in power. However, the Argentine political elite must realize that if it does not listen to its citizens’ demands and make the appropriate adjustments, the protests and unrest will continue.

 

Gabriela Garton, Research Associate at the Council on Hemispheric Affairs

Please accept this article as a free contribution from COHA, but if re-posting, please afford authorial and institutional attribution. Exclusive rights can be negotiated. 

________________________________

[1] Associated Press. “Argentina sees largest anti-government protests yet; many disapprove of economic management.” Washington Post. September 13, 2012. http://www.washingtonpost.com/business/argentina-sees-largest-anti-government-protests-yet-many-disapprove-of-economic-management/2012/09/13/c14e07d2-fe11-11e1-98c6-ec0a0a93f8eb_story.html. Accessed September 14, 2012.

[2] “‘Seguridad, libertad y justicia’, los principales reclamos de la gente.” Clarín. September 14, 2012. http://www.clarin.com/politica/cacerolazo-redes_sociales-movilizacion-Plaza_de_Mayo_0_773322931.html. Accessed September 14, 2012.

[3] “Argentina’s dubious poverty line. The six-peso diet: Rumbling stomachs, grumbling citizens.” The Economist. September 8, 2012. http://www.economist.com/node/21562238. Accessed September 14, 2012.

[4] “Medio centenar de muertos en un accidente ferroviario en Argentina.” El País. February 22, 2012.  http://internacional.elpais.com/internacional/2012/02/22/actualidad/1329921646_764629.html. Accessed September 14, 2012.

5 thoughts on “A Nation In Protest: The Return Of The Cacerolazos

  • September 17, 2012 at 8:42 pm
    Permalink

    Thanks for posting a very informative article! I hope you continue bringing these issues to light and providing factual information. Venezuela is also another country in which the black market specializing in currency trade has also become common, due to the instability of the national currency (bolivar). It is unfortunate when citizens feel financially and physically insecure….these fears, whether perceived or not, are factors that can lead to greater social issues and civil unrest in the future.

    Reply
  • September 19, 2012 at 5:09 am
    Permalink

    You call this research? This is just a compilation of the arguments of the Argentinean right wing opposition. Somehow I was under the impression that COHA was a kind of progressive outfit, but apparently you are just spoke-persons of some of the worst Latin American right wing groups.

    Reply
  • September 20, 2012 at 1:21 am
    Permalink

    I'm not well up on Argentine politics, but from the little I know the demonstrators are not right wing – quite the opposite. They are expressing the views of the working people. The article was merely reporting what happened on 13 Sept. we can only hope that the Government listens and things do not get ugly.

    Reply
  • September 21, 2012 at 6:14 am
    Permalink

    You are misinformed. The protestors are not all right wing. True. But many of them are. And they are not working people. They are from the middle and upper classes. Their protest is legitimate, but it is right wing. Furthermore, many, though not all of the protestors would support a military coup if that was an option (fortunately it isn't). Finally, the article is based only on opposition sources (like the newspaper Clarin) that are spoke people of the economic elites or international magazines like the Economist that have consistently opposed the government for its progressive measures (such as the renationalization of the pension system, the renationalization of the formerly national oil company, an industrial policy directed to reindustrialize the country, etc. There were not alternative views on the report. It took the ideas of the right wing opposition hook, line and sinker.
    .

    Reply
  • October 18, 2012 at 3:47 pm
    Permalink

    I spend two to three months in Argentina each year. The protestors against Cristina Kirchner are working people of all types. There are taxi drivers, fabric and leather sewers, bankers and both big and small business people, not to mention retired people and construction workers. Everyone who works and earns a living is getting increasingly frustrated with the diminishing amounts that their pesos can buy. Almost everyone I speak to is dreadfully upset at the 25% inflation, the corruption and the complete lack of imports allowed to enter the country. The protest is by all working people who simply want a calm, honest government. It is neither right wing nor left.

    Reply

Leave a Reply to Jose I Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *