|
Council On Hemispheric Affairs |
|
Monitoring
Political, Economic and Diplomatic Issues Affecting the Western
Hemisphere |
Tuesday,
August 2 2005
COMMENTARY FROM COHA
Congressional Inaction Will Lead to U.S. Surrender in the Colombian Drug War
Barring U.S. Congressional
action, Colombia will continue its near comatose condition as a blood-stained
narco-state living off the U.S. taxpayers’ dime. This is despite
the best of intentions of Republican and Democratic administrations
over the past decade. On Friday, July 22, President Álvaro
Uribe signed the controversial Ley de Justicia y Paz (Justice
and Peace Law), with specific U.S. backing. This measure sharply
reverses
fundamental strategies conceived by Colombia and Washington to curb
drug smuggling, brazenly compromising anti-drug objectives as never
before. The new law calls for maximum sanctions of no more than five
to eight years, a mere slap on the wrist for drug smugglers and vicious
human rights violators. In fact, some of Colombia’s worst human
rights violators and drug traffickers will be serving no more than
a year or two on country estate-like work farms. Most of all, the
new legislation circumvents mandatory extradition of those guilty
of crimes against American interests.
The new Colombian measure specifically protects members of the Autodefensas
Unidas de Colombia (AUC), a right-wing paramilitary/vigilante
group acknowledged as having racked up the most heinous drug and rights
record
in the country. The enactment of this law creates enormous holes in
the heart of a carefully crafted scheme aimed at eradicating the exportation
of narcotics from Colombia. Inevitably, such leniency will create a
new generation of cocaine “untouchables,” as The Guardian’s
Isabel Hilton has noted, and further stimulate the country’s
already-burgeoning cocaine industry.
The National Taxpayers Union Foundation recently voiced deep concern
about the funding for Plan Colombia, particularly “the continued
use of [U.S.] taxpayer dollars to support massive foreign aid that
has not shown positive results.” The plan’s costly anti-drug
measures have, at a minimum, failed to eliminate even a modest percentage
of narcotics exports. Additionally, the misnamed Justice and Peace
Law will protect top drug offenders from extradition and provide neither
peace nor justice to the average Colombian.
Colombia is the third highest recipient of U.S. aid, behind Israel
and Egypt. The Plan, developed during the Clinton administration, underwrites
the funding of now primarily military objectives designed to curtail
the flow of drugs from Colombia to the U.S. Total monetary support
for the plan over the last five years amounts to more than $3 billion.
After September 11, 2001, President Bush expanded its mission to include
an anti-terrorism initiative. With this aid in hand, Uribe has attempted
to restore order and curb violence in the country by declaring a State
of Limited Emergency soon after taking office in 2002. Uribe now aims
to weaken, if not eliminate, violence and drug-smuggling by the left-wing
Fuerzas Armadas Revolucionarios de Colombia (FARC) guerrillas, who
have been waging a war against Bogotá for the last forty years,
as well as, ostensibly, the right-wing (AUC) paramilitaries. Even though
a series of anti-narcotics plans have failed to staunch the drug flow
and curb violence in Colombia, the House has approved nearly $600 million
more in funds for the program which was to due to expire in September.
Washington and Bogotá’s dirty little secret here is that
although both countries insinuated that both FARC and AUC were “terrorist” organizations
and foes of democratic efforts in Colombia, there was never any doubt
that Uribe’s, and thus the U.S.’, campaign was targeted
against the leftist FARC and not the AUC, who the Colombian military
counted as allies.
This new law further thwarts a year-long Congressional effort, made
public in a letter to Uribe signed by 22 U.S. senators, to press for
the prosecution of Colombian officials who worked secretly in partnership
with the right-wing paramilitary commanders. The U.S. legislators expressed
concern that “There are reports of increased [human rights’]
violations, such as extrajudicial killings and forced disappearances,
attributed directly to Colombian security forces.”
Among the beneficiaries of this new law is Diego Murillo, a brutal
AUC commander who oversaw the extensive drug trade among paramilitaries,
and who found no problem in allegedly ordering the killing of those
associated with several heroic Bogotá legislators who were trying
to track down his network. Murillo is one of 18 commanders identified
by Washington as “deeply involved” in drug trafficking.
He was indicted in New York for widespread cocaine trafficking. He
is now one of a number of AUC members who have voluntarily surrendered
to Colombian justice officials to receive the mercifully lenient terms
of Uribe’s deal with the devil.
The death of Arnold Enrique Maza, puts a human face on the inhuman
scale of violence in today’s Colombia. Maza disappeared in Monteria,
Cordoba and his body was discovered June 12, 1997. He had been tortured
and then murdered by AUC operators, having suffered torment in unimaginable
ways. During a series of lawmakers’ deliberations, silent vigils
were held outside of the Colombian Congress to commemorate the victims
of the AUC’s brutal history.
Moreover, revelations came out that Uribe has several troubling personal
ties to the AUC, further underlying Washington’s compromised
anti-drug and anti-corruption efforts in Colombia. Uribe’s campaign
manager, Pedro Moreno Villa, was identified by U.S. Customs as the
largest importer of potassium permanganate, a chemical used in cocaine
production, between 1994 and 1998. In addition, as a presidential candidate,
Uribe purportedly received campaign contributions from a number of
AUC officials and other AUC-affiliated drug sources.
Colombia’s drug industry is booming despite the frequent fumigation
of the coca plant. The more than 1.3 million acres of coca plants destroyed
over the last five years have done little to dent the influx of Colombian-sourced
cocaine onto U.S. streets. The Colombian branch of the industry provides
90 percent of the cocaine being sent to this country. Ironically, the
$3 billion plus funding from Plan Colombia has yielded a three percent
increase in cocaine production. U.S. street value of one kilo of cocaine
has remained constant at between $10,000-36,000-a bad sign for a drug-eradication
program. The White House Office of National Drug Control Policy estimates
that purity has remained consistent as well.
The U.S. War on Drugs has failed in slashing the supply of narcotics
hitting the streets of its major cities. Continuing to financially
support nations like Colombia that protect drug offenders from extradition
and prospects for suitable sentencing for those found guilty cannot
achieve this objective, and sends a destructively mixed message about
Washington’s commitment to the anti-drug struggle. For now, this
flow continues unabated and sponsorship of this new Colombian law,
however underplayed, prevents the difficult struggle to achieve justice
against the AUC, Colombia’s most bloodthirsty state-terror group.
An estimated 14,000 have fallen victim to the AUC over the last two
decades alone. The Justice and Peace measure is an ill-conceived, if
potent, attempt to integrate AUC members into Colombian society by
painting over their brutal misdeeds, and is grossly counterproductive
to Washington’s stated objectives in the War on Drugs.
A freeze on Plan Colombia spending is called for until an overhaul
of tactics used in the war on drugs and a review of the status of the
AUC has been conducted by the U.S. Congress. If the status quo is maintained,
the U.S. will not be able to accomplish its counter-terrorism and counter-narcotics
objectives in Colombia, and thereby in all of South America. The Senate
is currently debating the renewal of funding for Plan Colombia through
2006. At this point it is imperative that U.S. lawmakers devise new
policies aimed at curtailing drug-smuggling and drug related violence
that can only destabilize a vital South American ally, and amount to
a de facto surrender to the AUC in the Colombia phase in war against
drugs. The U.S. can no longer provide a cover for Uribe’s transparent
efforts to give up the most potent weapon in the war against “terrorism”-
that is extradition of drug cartel leaders to the U.S.
This
analysis was prepared by COHA Research Associate Luis Morales.
August 2, 2005
The
Council on Hemispheric Affairs, founded in 1975, is an independent,
non-profit, non-partisan, tax-exempt research and information
organization. It has been described on the Senate floor as being “one
of the nation’s most respected bodies of scholars and policy
makers.” For more information, please see our web page at www.coha.org;
or contact our Washington offices by phone (202) 223-4975, fax
(202) 223-4979, or email coha@coha.org.
To subscribe to our free press releases, send an email to coha@coha.org
with "subscribe" as the subject. 1
COHA Commentary 05.16